Proottalfain's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Pursuit of the Knight]

doesnt have the melody

It has a catchy melody only around 1:30. The batman theme... I don't like it nor do I like how you played with it.

SinJim responds:

Hmm, well thanks for the review, everyone's got their own opinion.

~SinJim

[(NUB)I would have hated myself]

I'd like myself

Good song, touching, like always. My kid-self would have been proud of me, not because I accomplished many things (I got not much money, never had a GF, though I'm 17, got no car nor a driving license), but because I stand tall, while as a kid I was letting some guy not tougher than me stomp me. I've seen this guy last year (didn't see him for 4 years before that), and I'm sturdier than him physically and mentally.

nubbinownz responds:

That makes me really happy man. I'm glad that things got much better for you :) And that you would be happy with yourself .

[(NUB)Can This Last Forever]

not enough

You did much better on other songs, and I didn't like the piano starting around 1:00. I'ma go get my whip now. And to answer your question ("i'm curious as to how people are finding it hehe it's been buried for a while now."): each time one of your songs gains popularity, people who like your style listen all your "discography".

nubbinownz responds:

Ahhh thank you man, An 8 is still good in my eyes. Thank you for that. Yes, this is one of my older songs :D

[(NUB)Time To Let Go-beta-]

PLEASE, NO EMOTION!

Your damn emotional songs that touch right-to-the-heart just remind me that I'm a poor lonesome guy in need of a girlfriend. Conclusion: You succeeded at touching NG's heart, or at least mine. <off-topic>Now I wanna go shop for a new LCD panoramic monitor :P</off-topic>

nubbinownz responds:

I reccomend the optiquest 22 inch widescreen. It's got a really nice ms response and super crystal clear resolution :D

Thanks for the review man :D I appreciate it!

[Forelorn Lemons]

Ambient, yeah.

Indeed, it's ambient. It's the kind of song to listen while being concentrated on something else.

nubbinownz responds:

hehe yes it is. Thank you for the review man :D

[Space Blaster]

nah

Not enough things happening. I find this song somewhat... empty. Like space, one would say. Yeah, but space is boring. This is definitely not your best song.

nubbinownz responds:

hahahha yeah, this was actually like .. the 3rd or 4th song I ever made The only good thing I like about it is the guitar lead near the end.

[These Mistakes are Mine Alone]

reminds me of Linkin Park

The techno-style drum reminds me of linkin park, I hope you won't take it as an insult (Linkin Park doesn't have a good reputation on NG). I used to like Linkin when I was 13-14, and this song has the good part of it. Gratz (and also thank you for replying to my comment on «the fire»)

nubbinownz responds:

hehe i've learned to not take that one as an insult. I actually hear it alot on this track. :) Thank you again proot, your reviews are always a pleasure

[(NUB)The Fire]

Emotionnal 8-bit

I like it. Favorited because it's heart-touching. The 8-bitness gives it more emotion than a guitar would, it gives it an unreal feel, as if the person thinks his own life is distant... That was philosophical.

nubbinownz responds:

And i totally loved your review. It actually made alot of sense, it was not the intention of the song originally but definitely adds to the depth.

[Zendai - Tribu de Dana (5'45")]

Oh god

THANK YOU! I always thought that song was wasting the potential of its beat. The original song sounds corny and when people talk about it, it's to say how pathetic it is. You succeeded in making it good. I remember when the original song was playing at the radio, I think we were still in the 20th century.

Yytrium responds:

Yes the original is rather old. And indeed it's a bit too corny for my likings but the tune of that melody had some kind of power hidden inside :) I just had to do something with it. Too bad I sucked at Fruity Loops when I made this. This could have been even better.

[Les Guignols de L'info]

Salut bonhomme

It gets annoying, but you did a good job making a song with such random things.

vlequang responds:

merci, et a tchao bonsoir!